Each time I meet with a physical therapist, they ask me the same question: “What can I do to help my clients recover psychologically from their injuries?”
Therapists work with athletes who are unmotivated, depressed, paralyzed by fear, anxious, uncommitted, and doubtful, among other things. Some of the simplest and most effective approaches physical therapists can take come from one of the most influential theories in sport psychology: Self-Determination Theory (SDT).
SDT identifies three core principles that influence human motivation: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. When physical therapists put these principles into practice, they subtly and powerfully encourage individuals to move toward their goals. Athletes develop intrinsic motivation that can propel them through recovery and beyond. The goal of every physical therapist, athletic trainer, and support staff member is to help clients see and pursue the vision of healing and performance that they envision, but the athlete may not yet see for themselves.
Autonomy
All people have a need for autonomy. The need for control, influence, and independence in our lives is a powerful force within each of us. We strive for a sense of autonomy because a total lack of control can create discomfort and fear of the unknown. When athletes are given opportunities to choose their path, even in small ways, their belief in their ability to heal and their commitment to each exercise grows beyond what would otherwise be the case.1
A sense of autonomy is a catalyst for investment and ownership. Consider a college student who pays at least part of their own tuition and performs better academically than a student whose parents pay for everything.2 Similarly, an athlete who actively participates in the recovery process, rather than simply completing assigned exercises, demonstrates a greater commitment to the journey. When athletes have a greater sense of autonomy, better follow through with workouts, complete additional work when possible, ask for help, seek opportunities for physical and emotional development, develop hope, and increase their self-efficacy.3
Autonomy is the fulfillment of an individual’s need to feel that they have influence and power in their current situation. When people become accustomed to following commands, orders, and instructions without having a say in the process, they begin to lose interest and engagement declines. Consistent opportunities for authentic control give people a sense of worth, while having choices creates investment and ownership.
When a sense of autonomy is entirely removed from the process, investment decreases. When both interest and investment are lost, behavior is negatively affected. This can show up as an athlete not pushing themselves, skipping or failing to complete workouts, or cutting corners. Autonomy provides a sense of purpose and control. It also strengthens an individual’s belief in a positive outcome while improving their intrinsic motivation to complete the task, in this case, recovery.4
Ways to foster autonomy in injured athletes:
Give athletes opportunities to help build and choose their workouts when possible.
Allow athletes to choose the order in which they complete their exercises.
Include athletes in goal-setting conversations and help them establish goals that are personally meaningful and relevant to their sport.
Ask questions such as, “What part of your recovery feels most within your control, and what part feels out of your control?”
Explore why the athlete wants to recover. Encourage them to recognize and discuss their emotions, and remind them of the driving forces behind their commitment to recovery.
Competence
One of the biggest roadblocks in recovery is the unknown. Doubt and uncertainty can lead to fear, and fear can contribute to feelings of depression and disconnection. Often, clients are unsure of the anatomical specifics of their injuries, the expected recovery timeline, and, most importantly, when they will be able to play again.
By developing competence, athletes gain knowledge and understanding of their bodies and their situations. This can replace doubt and fear with understanding, confidence, trust, and hope. When they talk to others about their injuries, they understand what is happening and are less likely to feel uncomfortable or uninformed. Throughout the recovery process, clients can begin to see the road ahead of them and take ownership of their journeys.
Competence also encompasses a person’s ability, or perception of their ability, to accomplish something. In this case, that something is recovery. Confidence is born from success. “Success begets success because it changes the way we see ourselves.”7 Daily and weekly victories inspire and motivate athletes throughout recovery. When people recognize their growth, their belief in their ability to continue growing increases. When we anchor the knowledge of success into the heart and mind of the client, they begin to drive themselves toward greater and greater success.
Ways to foster competence in injured athletes:
Provide athletes with an anatomical understanding of what happened during their injuries, what occurred during surgery, and what to expect throughout the treatment process.
Help athletes understand what will be required of them throughout recovery.
Provide balanced and helpful feedback. Cheer athletes on and reassure them when necessary, while also offering constructive criticism that encourages improvement.
Give athletes small, achievable goals along the way. Vague and distant goals can create feelings of incompetence, contributing to hopelessness and potentially damage the relationship between the athlete and therapist.
Help athletes track their progress and look back on their growth when appropriate. Recognizing improvements, even small ones, can provide motivation and build confidence.
Normalize the recovery experience by helping athletes understand that others have experienced similar injuries and successfully recovered. Knowing that others have traveled this road before them can provide hope and a recognizable path forward.
Relatedness
Relatedness arises from and is closely intertwined with a foundational theory of relationships: Attachment Theory. Attachment Theory proposes that one of the primary functions of healthy relationships is to provide both a safe haven and a launching pad for individuals.
Secure attachment gives individuals a home base, a place where they can be themselves and express authenticity. A launching pad implies that individuals have the confidence and ability to propel themselves forward, even when they are not physically near their attachment figure. In the recovery process, a client who develops a secure attachment with their physical therapist may be more motivated and confident when approaching and engaging in difficult tasks, both in the physical therapy office and on their own. This is particularly important when the client is away from the person with whom they have developed that connection.
Ways to foster relatedness in injured athletes:
Prioritize two-way communication. Give athletes opportunities to provide input while continuing to offer instruction and guidance. Work as a team.
Actively listen. Use open body language, maintain eye contact, provide undivided attention, seek understanding through responses, and validate emotions.
Build personal connections. Share appropriate things about your life, show genuine curiosity about theirs, and become someone they feel comfortable talking to.
Strengthen rapport through the application of the other two principles: autonomy and competence.
Avoid blaming athletes for their injuries or lack of progress. Instead, work together as a team to overcome challenges.
Find a balance between encouraging athletes toward a return to sport and performance while emphasizing the importance of their long-term health.
Above all, see and treat the person, not just the athlete but as a person. Sport is only one part of their identity.
Conclusion
As someone who strives to contribute to an athlete’s recovery, I hope I have been able to provide some insights and examples of how you can help heal the mind of the athlete as well as the body. Motivation happens at the intersection of autonomy, competence, and relatedness, both in the training room and in life.
As athletes step into their next challenge, let us all strive to fill them with courage, hope, and a belief in their future.
References
Bejar, M. P., Raabe, J., Zakrajsek, R. A., Fisher, L. A., & Clement, D. (2019). Athletic trainers' influence on national collegiate athletic association division I athletes' basic psychological needs during sport injury rehabilitation. Journal of Athletic Training, 54(3), 245-254. https://nata.kglmeridian.com/view/journals/attr/54/3/article-p245.xml
Bodvarsson, Ö. B., & Walker, R. L. (2004). Do parental cash transfers weaken performance in college?. Economics of Education Review, 23(5), 483-495. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0272775704000056?via%3Dihub
Chan, N. S., Khoo, S., & Low, W. Y. (2012). Self-determination and goal orientation in track and field. Journal of human kinetics, 33, 151. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3588670/
Meng, L., & Ma, Q. (2015). Live as we choose: The role of autonomy support in facilitating intrinsic motivation. International Journal of Psychophysiology, 98(3), 441-447. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0167876015300258
Jackson Cheadle, Carrie & Kuzma, Cindy. (2019). Rebound: Train your mind to bounce back stronger from sports injuries. Bloomsbury Sport.
Van Yperen, N. W. (2025). Athletes’ basic psychological need satisfaction and autonomous motivation: Differences between individual vs. team sports. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 7, 1592356. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41306187/
Waters, D. B., & Lawrence, E. C. (1993). Competence, courage, and change: An approach to family therapy. W.W. Norton & Co.